Peter Wins Controversial Decision Over Toney
September 3rd, 2006 - By Frank Gonzalez Jr., photo bs Tom Casino / Showtime -Sharkie’s Machine: In a WBC Heavyweight Eliminator bout Saturday night at the Staples Center in Los Angeles, 233-pound James “Lights Out” Toney (69-5-3-1, 43 KO’s) faced 257-pound power puncher, Samuel “The Nigerian Nightmare” Peter (27-1, 22 KO’s).
The consensus among fight fans was that either Toney would win by decision or Peter would win by knock out. Who would’ve guessed that Peter would win by decision?
Though that’s how it will show on the record, the truth is that James Toney landed the cleaner punches at a higher percentage and for 12 rounds, was able to prevent Peter from landing anything particularly flush. Peter showed some improvements in his skills but against the superior boxer that is James Toney, it’s my opinion that Peter lost most of the rounds.
Toney consistently landed his jab and combinations inside and frustrated Peter, testing his stamina till the end. Peter’s best moments came in the third, fifth, tenth and twelfth rounds, when he was able to do more damage.
It was Peter who looked the worse for wear after twelve rounds. Peter’s mouth and nose were bleeding, his eyes swollen and looking worse for wear than Toney. Toney had out worked and out boxed Peter for the seven of the first eight rounds with jabs, slick defensive mobility and superior ring generalship. Peter was sloppier, winging power punches that were mostly missing the mark and rarely landing cleanly.
Action slowed a bit after the eighth and Peter lost a point for throwing a double earmuff punch during a break in the ninth round.
At times, Peter was able to stun Toney with a few fair shots but Toney took them well and always answered with crisper punches. Though Peter rocked Toney a couple of times, Toney showed a great chin and managed to stun Peter more than a few times himself, while winning most of the rounds. Peter did manage to win the final round by out working Toney.
I score rounds based on clean punching, ring generalship and defense. I don’t know what the criteria are for Dick Flaherty and Alejandro Rochin, who saw the fight in reverse of what I saw.
The official scores were 115-112 for Toney and 116-111 twice for Peter, who won a very questionable split decision. Considering the point deduction for Peter in the ninth, I had it 116-112 in favor of James Toney.
During the post fight interview, Peter was very complimentary of Toney, remarking how strong he was and how well he took a big punch. Peter tried to embrace Toney in a show of good sportsmanship but Toney wasn’t particularly interested in any niceties after hearing the Official scores. At 38 years old, Toney doesn’t have time for bogus decisions in what should be the twilight of his career.
When Toney was interviewed, he said that he definitely won the fight. He said, “Look at my face and look at his, how the hell did he win that fight?” He was right. In his anger, Toney started a ruckus in the ring aimed at Peter’s Manager. Peter was whisked away to the locker room as the cooler heads in the ring cordoned Toney off.
Considering the wild scoring from Press Row, the Official Judges and whoever else was keeping score, James Toney at the least, deserves a rematch.
This questionable result sets Sam Peter up to face WBC Champion, Oleg Maskaev next for the Title.
* * *
Comments can be emailed to dshark87@hotmail.com
Peter Decisions Toney, Guerrero Dominates Aiken to Win Title
LOS ANGELES (Sept. 2, 2006) – Photo by Tpm Casino / Showtime - Samuel Peter proved to be James Toney’s worst nightmare Saturday on SHOWTIME. In a hard-fought heavyweight brawl that featured excellent exchanges and few clinches, Peter registered a hotly disputed, 12-round split decision over Toney in a World Boxing Council (WBC) elimination bout at STAPLES Center in Los Angeles.
In the SHOWTIME CHAMPIONSHIP BOXING co-feature, Robert “The Ghost’’ Guerrero dominated defending champion Eric “Mighty Mouse” Aiken to win the International Boxing Federation (IBF) featherweight title. The champion’s corner stopped the fight after the eighth round and the bout was declared a technical knockout.
The Toney-Peter WBC eliminator was presented by Goossen Tutor Promotions, Don King Productions and Duva Boxing. The Guerrero-Aiken championship bout was promoted by Goossen Tutor Promotions in association with Art Pellulo’s Banner Promotions. Both bouts aired on SHOWTIME at 10 p.m. ET/PT (delayed on the west coast).
By triumphing 116-111 twice and 112-115, Peter, of Las Vegas, Nev., by way of Akwaibom, Nigeria, becomes the mandatory challenger to WBC heavyweight champion Oleg Maskaev. Peter’s biggest victory in the most important fight of his career came four days shy of his 26th birthday.
“I want Oleg,” said a jubilant Peter (27-1, 22 KOs), who entered the ring as the WBC No. 3 contender. “Toney never hurt me. I am solid like a rock. My game plan was to stick the jab. He picked some off, but it was working all night long. The trash talking before didn’t affect me at all.’’
Toney (69-5-2, 43 KOs), a former three-time world champion of Los Angeles, by way of Grand Rapids, Mich., was incredulous about the decision.
“Peter didn’t do (expletive withheld),’’ said Toney, 38, the WBC No. 2 contender going in. “I’m not done with him. Hey, this is a joke. I didn’t lose the fight. I took everything away from him.
“I am not old. I am not fat and out of shape like Larry Holmes. This is not over. We are going to protest.’’
Guerrero (19-1-1, 12 KOs) of Gilroy, Calif., outclassed and outhustled Aiken and won nearly every round on each of the scorecards in the first world title fight between “ShoBox: The New Generation’’ alums.
“I was in control the whole time,” said Guerrero, who led 80-71 twice and 79-72 when the match was stopped after the eighth round by the referee at the request of Aiken’s corner. “To say I am happy would be an understatement. We executed everything we worked on in camp.
“I want to fight the best guys. That is what the fans want.’’
Aiken (16-5, 12 KOs), of Marysville, Ohio, had a two-fight winning streak snapped. The champion made his first IBF defense since scoring a shocking victory over previously unbeaten titleholder Valdemir Pereira on May 13, 2006.
“Everything Guerrero did affected me,” Aiken said. “I broke my fight hand. (But) I am not taking anything away from him.’’
WBC Lightweight Champion Diego “Chico” Corrales joined SHOWTIME CHAMPIONSHIP BOXING’s Steve Albert and Al Bernstein from ringside as special guest analyst. Jim Gray was the roving reporter and Karyn Bryant was special correspondent. The executive producer of the SHOWTIME telecast was David Dinkins, Jr., with Bob Dunphy directing
Corrales offered his unique insight to the Aiken-Guerrero co-feature, having sparred with Guerrero in the past, and an overall knowledge of the lighter weight divisions. It was Corrales’ debut behind the microphone. The network has used fighters in this role before, notably Mike Tyson, Bobby Czyz and Sugar Ray Leonard.
“It was a blast,” Corrales said. “To be honest, it was more work than I expected …. between rehearsals, notes and reviewing video tapes. I think I added something to the show, things that come only with in-ring experience.’’
In addition to Monday night, Saturday’s fight also will be replayed in its entirety on SHOWTIME TOO at 11 p.m. ET/PT on Tuesday, June 6.
Corrales will return to his more familiar role as prizefighter when the 20th anniversary celebration of SHOWTIME CHAMPIONSHIP BOXING continues on Saturday, Oct. 7 (9 p.m. ET/PT, delayed on the west coast). In the main event, Corrales will defend his WBC belt in a grudge rubber match against heated rival, former 130-pound world champion Joel Casamayor.
A pint-sized powerhouse with heavyweight power in either fist, unbeaten Vic “The Raging Bull’’ Darchinyan will risk his IBF and IBO flyweight belts against Glenn “The Filipino Bomber” Donaire in the co-feature at Mandalay Bay Resort & Casino in Las Vegas.
One night before the excellent world championship doubleheader, the “ShoBox” The New Generation” super middleweight tournament continues with two semifinal bouts (11 p.m. ET/PT delayed on the west coast.
SHOWTIME CHAMPIONSHIP BOXING celebrates 20 years of hard-hitting, explosive programming in 2006. In March 1986, SHOWTIME CHAMPIONSHIP BOXING was born when “Marvelous” Marvin Hagler defeated John “The Beast” Mugabi in a spectacular and unforgettable 11th-round knockout in Las Vegas. Since that time, the network has aired some of the most historic and significant events in the sport including both Evander Holyfield-Mike Tyson bouts.
Always at the forefront of boxing, SHOWTIME has set itself apart by televising “great fights, no rights” on the first Saturday of every month. SHOWTIME is the first network to regularly deliver live boxing in High Definition. In addition, SHOWTIME continues to be a pioneer in sports television with a number of interactive features across multiple platforms making SHOWTIME CHAMPIONSHIP BOXING the most enjoyable, immersive viewing experience for the boxing audience.
For information on SHOWTIME CHAMPIONSHIP BOXING and “ShoBox: The New Generation” telecasts, including complete fighter bios and records, related stories and more, please go the SHOWTIME website at http://www.sho.com/boxing.
|
